In 1980, Isaac Asimov talked about a “Cult of Ignorance” in America where the public didn’t listen to “experts” as much as he thought they should. I want to explain why many educated people are not only wrong, but dangerous. Dr. Thomas Sowell calls those who think others should listen to them “self-anointed.” He explains three cases in his book Intellectuals and Society.
- - -
First, some people who are brilliant in a specific field receive no attention in their neighborhood supermarket because the field is abstract and specialized. They are indeed noteworthy and brilliant but feel unappreciated. They offer advice and opinions in other fields and expect to be heeded because of their brilliance in their primary field. But they have no more expertise elsewhere than the ordinary citizen.
- - -
Doctors, architects, engineers, and others are held responsible if things go wrong after their advice is followed. Other “experts” specialize in fields where being wrong costs the practitioner nothing. These “intellectuals” manage to shift the blame or simply explain that their plan was carried out incorrectly or that more money will solve it. Even when the public complains about “whole word” reading instead of phonics, or some wonderful way to teach mathematics, the experts aren’t blamed when students don’t learn.
- - -
Sowell also talks about the difference between group wisdom and the theoretical wisdom of planners and experts. Here he seems to be talking about Adam Smith’s “Invisible Hand,” but it is much simpler. Every planned economy produces too much of some things and too little of others. Price controls always produce shortages.
An open price system lets buyers and sellers tell each other what is needed and what should be produced. By letting the group share information, a “wiser” set of answers is produced. It may not be some “ideal” answer, but it meets the needs or desires of the community.
- - -
A far more dangerous version of intellectual expertise has been building recently. Peter Turchin explains it in End Times: Elites, Counter-Elites, and the Path of Political Disintegration. We have produced a surplus of people trained for leadership. He describes the world as a game of musical chairs with a fixed number of leadership chairs.
The West has produced more degreed people, especially lawyers, than there are leadership positions to fill. Two things happen. People are willing to pay very high prices to pursue political office and gain such a position. They also stop caring about getting it honestly or with integrity. Even if some people still care, an ever-increasing number, and their backers, with vast resources, don’t.
In that system, proving you are “purer and holier” than the other fellow is essential. You can never stand out in a way where you can be attacked and chopped down. You can’t question the beauty and glory of the Emperor’s robes. Any doubter is ruthlessly attacked and has no chance of survival, let alone advancement.
- - -
Classicist and historian Victor Davis Hanson of Stanford’s Hoover Institution was interviewed by John Papola in a YouTube video. He described a large group of graduates.
They are downwardly mobile, highly educated, mostly white children of the professional and upper middle classes. And they insist on living in blue areas like Denver, Boston, New York, Washington, San Francisco, where there’s culture, and they feel that they’re educated.
They rub shoulders with very wealthy people, Wall Street, media, insurance execs, CEOs, etc. I meet them all the time because I published with New York publishers, and I met them for 40 years, and they’re highly educated, and you talk to them, and they’re making $50,000, and they have titles like senior editor at Alfred Knopf, or they are Greenpeace vice president, and they’re making nothing, and they have these high rents and high costs.
They don’t own cars, and they don’t get married till they’re 35, and they have one child, if any, and they’re very unhappy people. And they’re downwardly mobile, and so they have become critics of the entire system
They have their own set of truths about who is welcome in inner circles. He describes, contrary to “white superiority”, that white males are excluded.
I was the head of eight hiring committees, and I was told, “If you hire a white male, we will not sign it. You understand that, Victor?” And I said, “ Well, this candidate’s so much better”. “You understand that? We will not hire them.”
Certain answers in science are forbidden, and areas of research are forbidden territory. Many people find it absurd when courts let naked men in sororities and women’s locker rooms. We can’t comprehend phrases like “chest feeding.” But it comes from an absolute hatred of ordinary people.
… they think that the middle class lacks the romance of the poor and the sophistication and culture of the wealthy … They really do hate the middle class. They hate everything about them. I hear them every day when I’m in the Bay Area. You know, sometimes it’s their trucks, sometimes it’s their Winnebago, sometimes it’s their jet skis, their snowmobiles. The epitome of all of it wasn’t Trump. It was Sarah Palin. That was the one locus they focused all their hatred on: middle-class America.
As a result, they hate everything the middle class understands as underpinning a stable society: truth, law, order, borders, morality, family, tradition. Jonathan Haidt described two types of people in The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion. The interplay between tradition and change is valuable in a society where both sides respect each other and agree to play by the rules.
We aren’t there anymore. These people feel so unappreciated; they don’t just feel the rules are wrong; they know they are.
So, rules be damned. If they must destroy society to change the rules, they will.

